Richard

This book was always going to make noise. The Manics haven't been too happy with it. Their fans, the most loyal of any band in the country, have given it mixed reviews. It comes with a degree of rock controversy. Which, in a way, does it some good.

But what is the book? It is half psychological study of Richey Edwards, trying to get into his head, narrating its way through his childhood memories, his thoughts about his current life, his difficulty with being a cult icon, juxtaposed with small town origins, friendships with band members and a growing interest in the darker times in history. The other half is more of a fleshed-out telling of what we know, with artistic licence filling in the gaps of what we don't. It imagines a fate for Richey that does culminate with the Severn Bridge, as has been long spectulated. The book is nothing if not brave.

Once you disconnect the reality from the storytelling, you have a powerful psychological study on your hands. The problem I had reading it was that events described all happened within my sphere of reference, being a teenager at the time. The stronger parts are Richey's internal monologue, which you're able to give more suspension of disbelief to.

It's a talking point book that will inspire debate for ages, especially given the die-hard nature of Manic Street Preachers fans. When it's good, it's great- when it's not, it's just I remember devouring the NME during those times only too well.
This is Ben Myers' truth, tell him yours.